90+ Wine Club

Wine publications will often rate wines on a 100 point scale and while an imperfect system and certainly no replacement for your own palate, it is often helpful as a guide in selecting wines from what can seem like an overwhelming number of choices. Here we have highlighted wines with only a 90 point score and above from the most respected wine publications.

29 Items

per page
Set Descending Direction
  1. Au Bon Climat Bien Nacido Vineyard Pinot Noir 2016

    Au Bon Climat Bien Nacido Vineyard Pinot Noir 2016

    $44.99
    • Vinous Rating: 96
    • Size: 750mL
    • Country: USA
    • Region: California
  2. Blindfold Ca White Blend

    Blindfold CA White Blend 2015

    $29.99
    • Wine Advocate Rating: 90
    • Size: 750ML
    • Country: USA
    • Region: California
  3. Caldwell Propietary Red

    Caldwell Propietary Red 2004

    $97.99
    • Wine Advocate Rating: 93
    • Size: 750ML
    • Country: USA
    • Region: California
  4. Chalone Chardonnay

    Chalone Chardonnay 2014

    $26.99
    • Wine Spectator Rating: 90
    • Size: 750ML
    • Country: USA
    • Region: California
  5. Cline Ancient Zinfandel

    Cline Cellars Ancient Vines Zinfandel 2017

    $16.99
    • Rating: 91
    • Size: 750ML
    • Country: USA
    • Region: California
  6. Clos Du Val Cabernet Napa

    Clos Du Val Cabernet Sauvignon 2015

    Sale Price $44.99 Regular Price $69.99
    • Wine Advocate Rating: 90
    • Size: 750ML
    • Country: USA
    • Region: California

    Sale wines count toward discount quantity but don't discount

  7. Daou Cabernet Reserve

    Daou Cabernet Sauvignon Reserve 2014

    $59.99
    • Wine Advocate Rating: 91
    • Size: 750ML
    • Country: USA
    • Region: California
  8. Failla Pinot Noir Sonoma Coast

    Failla Pinot Noir Sonoma Coast 2016

    $39.99
    • Antonio Galloni Rating: 90
    • Size: 750ML
    • Country: USA
    • Region: California
  9. Galerie Latro Knights Valley Cabernet

    Galerie Latro Knights Valley Cabernet 2013

    $54.99
    • Wine Advocate Rating: 91
    • Size: 750ML
    • Country: USA
    • Region: California
  10. Groth Cabernet Sauvignon

    Groth Cabernet Sauvignon 2015

    Sale Price $59.99 Regular Price $79.99
    • Rating: 92
    • Size: 750ML
    • Country: USA
    • Region: California

    Sale wines count toward discount quantity but don't discount

  11. Hall Cabernet

    Hall Cabernet Sauvignon 2016

    Sale Price $57.99 Regular Price $77.99
    • Rating: 91
    • Size: 750ML
    • Country: USA
    • Region: California

    Sale wines count toward discount quantity but don't discount

  12. Hartford Court Chardonnay Rr

    Hartford Court Russian River Chardonnay 2017

    $32.99
    • Rating: 93
    • Size: 750ML
    • Country: USA
    • Region: California
  13. Janzen Estate Cabernet Cloudy Vyd

    Janzen Estate Cabernet Sauvignon Cloudy's Vineyard 2012

    $139.99
    • Wine Advocate Rating: 92
    • Size: 750ML
    • Country: USA
    • Region: California
  14. Phelps Insignia

    Joseph Phelps Winery INSIGNIA 2013

    $299.99
    • Wine Advocate Rating: 98
    • Size: 750ML
    • Country: USA
    • Region: California
  15. Marietta Cellars Christo 2015

    Marietta Cellars Christo 2015

    $20.99
    • Wine Advocate Rating: 91
    • Size: 750ML
    • Country: USA
    • Region: California
  16. Martinelli Pinot Noir Lolita Ranch

    Martinelli Lolita Ranch Pinot Noir 2017

    $67.99
    • Rating: 94
    • Size: 750ML
    • Country: USA
    • Region: California
  17. Melville Chardonnay 2016

    Melville Chardonnay 2016

    $29.99
    • Vinous Rating: 92
    • Size: 750mL
    • Region: California
  18. Merry Edwards Sauvignon Blanc

    Merry Edwards M Edwards Sauvignon Blanc 2017

    $44.99
    • Wine Spectator Rating: 90
    • Size: 750ML
    • Country: USA
    • Region: California
  19. Merryvale Cabernet

    Merryvale Cabernet Sauvignon 2014

    $67.99
    • Rating: 91
    • Size: 750ML
    • Country: USA
    • Region: California
  20. Opus One

    Opus One Opus One 2015

    $369.99
    • James Suckling Rating: 98
    • Size: 750ML
    • Country: USA
    • Region: California
  21. Phelps Insignia

    Phelps Insignia 2014

    Sale Price $199.99 Regular Price $279.99
    • Wine Advocate Rating: 97
    • Size: 750ML
    • Country: USA
    • Region: California

    Sale wines count toward discount quantity but don't discount

  22. Pride Mountain Vineyards Merlot 2015

    Pride Mountain Vineyards Merlot 2015

    $92.99
    • Wine Advocate Rating: 94
    • Size: 750ML
    • Country: USA
    • Region: California
  23. Ridge Lytton Estate Petite Sirah

    Ridge Lytton Estate Petite Sirah 2015

    $37.99
    • Wine Advocate Rating: 90
    • Size: 750ML
    • Country: USA
    • Region: California
  24. Ridge Pagani Ranch Zinfandel

    Ridge Pagani Ranch Zinfandel 2015

    $42.99
    • Antonio Galloni Rating: 94
    • Size: 750ML
    • Country: USA
    • Region: California
  25. Tenshen White Blend

    Tenshen White 2016

    Sale Price $23.99 Regular Price $29.99
    • Wine Spectator Rating: 92
    • Size: 750ML
    • Country: USA
    • Region: California

    Sale wines count toward discount quantity but don't discount

  26. Togni Cabernet Tanbark Hill

    Togni Cabernet Sauvignon Tanbark Hill 2014

    $54.99
    • Antonio Galloni Rating: 90
    • Size: 750ML
    • Country: USA
    • Region: California
  27. Truchard Chardonnay Carneros

    Truchard Chardonnay 2015

    $29.99
    • Wine Spectator Rating: 91
    • Size: 750ML
    • Country: USA
    • Region: California
  28. Tyler Santa Barbara County Pinot Noir

    Tyler Winery Santa Barbara County Pinot Noir 2016

    $32.99
    • Wine Advocate Rating: 90
    • Size: 750ML
    • Country: USA
    • Region: California
  29. Whitehall Lane Tre Leoni

    Whitehall Lane Tre Leoni 2012

    $29.99
    • James Suckling Rating: 92
    • Size: 750ML
    • Country: USA
    • Region: California

29 Items

per page
Set Descending Direction